Local SEO3 min readUpdated November 13, 2026

Local SEO Audit Checklist - Find What's Costing You Calls

A practical local SEO audit checklist: Google Business Profile, website, citations, links, reviews and competitors. Find the gaps holding you back.

Muhammad Tufail AbbasFounder, SMBify · local SEO since 2013
⚡Key takeawaysThe short version
  • A local SEO audit compares where you are with where the businesses above you are, area by area.
  • Check six things: Google Business Profile, website, citations, links, reviews and tracking.
  • The goal isn't a 50-page report. It's a short, ranked list of fixes, biggest gap first.
  • Repeat a lighter version every quarter.
Contents
  1. Before you start: pick your keywords and competitors
  2. 1. Google Business Profile
  3. 2. Website
  4. 3. Citations
  5. 4. Links
  6. 5. Reviews
  7. 6. Tracking
  8. Turning the audit into a plan
  9. Get a free audit

#Before you start: pick your keywords and competitors

Write down:

  • 3-5 main services you want more calls for ("water heater repair", "AC installation").
  • Your main city and 2-3 nearby cities.
  • The 3 businesses that show in the map pack for your main service in your main city.

Everything below is measured against those competitors.

#1. Google Business Profile

  • Is the profile verified and do you have owner access?
  • Is the business name your real name, without added keywords?
  • Is the primary category the most specific fit for your main service? What do the top 3 use?
  • Are secondary categories relevant and complete?
  • Are all services listed, with descriptions?
  • Are service areas accurate (not too broad, not missing key cities)?
  • Hours, phone and website correct?
  • Photos: how many, how recent, real or stock?
  • Posts: when was the last one?
  • Q&A: answered, or full of random public questions?
  • Any duplicate profiles for your business?

Use our Google Business Profile optimization checklist for the details.

#2. Website

  • Is there one page per main service?
  • Do title tags include the service and city? See title tags for contractor websites.
  • Is name, address and phone on every page, matching Google exactly?
  • Click-to-call button visible on mobile?
  • Page speed on mobile acceptable? See is your website too slow.
  • Are pages indexed? Search site:yourdomain.com and see what shows.
  • City or area pages: real local content or swapped names?
  • LocalBusiness schema on the site? See LocalBusiness schema markup.
  • Any broken pages, old services you no longer offer, or contact forms that don't work?

#3. Citations

  • Search your business name, phone and address (and old ones).
  • Are you listed on the core platforms: Apple, Bing, Yelp, Facebook, BBB, Nextdoor, Angi, Houzz?
  • Any old phone numbers, old addresses or duplicates?
  • Are trade and local directories covered?

Details in NAP consistency.

  • How many websites link to you (referring domains)?
  • How does that compare with the top 3 competitors?
  • Are your links relevant (local, trade) or junk?
  • Any easy wins missing: suppliers, associations, chamber, sponsors?

See how many backlinks do I need.

#5. Reviews

  • Your review count and rating vs. the top 3.
  • How many new reviews in the last 90 days, for you and for them?
  • Do you reply to every review?
  • Is there a simple system to ask every customer?

#6. Tracking

  • Can you tell how many calls come from Google each month?
  • Do you check Google profile Performance (calls, directions, website clicks)?
  • Do you know your map rankings across your area, not just from your office? See Google Maps rank grid.

#Turning the audit into a plan

Put every finding into one of three groups:

  1. Fix now (quick, high impact): wrong category, missing services, wrong phone numbers, duplicate listings, no review link.
  2. Build next (weeks): missing service pages, citation cleanup, foundational links, review system.
  3. Ongoing (months): relationship links, local content, steady reviews, weekly posts.

Start with the biggest gap between you and the top 3. If they have 200 reviews and you have 20, reviews come first. If they all use a different primary category, fix that today.

#Get a free audit

Don't want to do it yourself? We'll run this audit for you and send a short, plain-English fix list. Request a free audit.

Next steps

Updated November 13, 2026
Muhammad Tufail Abbas, founder of SMBify
About the author

Muhammad Tufail Abbas

Founder of SMBify. In local SEO since 2013, working only with US home-service contractors: plumbers, HVAC, roofers and more. Every client gets a line-by-line log of the work.

Want this done for you?

We handle it, every week.

Google profile, website, citations, links and reviews. No contract, every task logged.

Get my free audit →See plans
WhatsApp